vvs/sim-numerics
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

the wide-bracket gap is NOT closed, and now it has an address: the STEP RULE, not the guarantee and not the reading places. fun1 is one function at growing widths — 7/8, 12/12, 19/15, 59/24, 63/44 — so we tie when narrow and lose as it widens, while our observed order is the HIGHER one (3.63 vs 2.02); 59 on a 2e4 bracket is what bisection needs, i.e. one halving per evaluation against their 2.3. With the safeguard removed entirely we still spend 46/57/61/68 against bisection 57/77/45/45 and Chandrupatla 24/44 — worse than bisection on two of them. |f|/|f'| is an absolute length and cannot march across decades; written into the paper as the stated limit. Also fixed a tracer bug that had best_of double-counting evaluations (2993 vs 1487)

Browse Source 
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
vvs
2026-09-21 00:09:18 +01:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5
parent 8d20816163
commit 0fb75be3cf
8 changed files with 372 additions and 6 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
results_cha_phases.txt
+63
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,63 @@
problem ours app/end CH app/end gap app gap end
fun1.1 5/2 6/2 -1 +0
fun1.2 10/2 10/2 +0 +0
fun1.3 11/8 13/2 -2 +6
fun1.4 20/39 21/3 -1 +36
fun1.5 3/60 3/41 +0 +19
fun2.1 7/2 7/2 +0 +0
fun2.2 23/3 20/3 +3 +0
fun2.3 27/3 25/4 +2 -1
fun2.4 1/42 2/40 -1 +2
fun2.5 1/48 2/47 -1 +1
fun3.1 32/32 21/23 +11 +9
fun3.2 28/28 23/23 +5 +5
fun3.3 31/35 28/32 +3 +3
fun3.4 31/42 28/41 +3 +1
fun3.5 3/82 3/79 +0 +3
fun4.1 30/24 21/23 +9 +1
fun4.2 30/26 23/23 +7 +3
fun4.3 32/38 29/27 +3 +11
fun4.4 28/45 30/37 -2 +8
fun4.5 3/83 3/77 +0 +6
fun5.1 30/27 22/22 +8 +5
fun5.2 28/26 22/22 +6 +4
fun5.3 27/28 22/23 +5 +5
fun5.4 31/26 22/25 +9 +1
fun5.5 31/28 22/26 +9 +2
fun6.1 29/23 22/22 +7 +1
fun6.2 29/25 22/22 +7 +3
fun6.3 25/25 22/23 +3 +2
fun6.4 25/27 22/25 +3 +2
fun6.5 25/30 22/26 +3 +4
fun7.1 11/0 8/0 +3 +0
fun7.2 11/0 8/0 +3 +0
fun7.3 11/0 11/0 +0 +0
fun7.4 11/0 18/0 -7 +0
fun7.5 13/0 19/0 -6 +0
fun8.1 11/2 8/2 +3 +0
fun8.2 9/2 9/2 +0 +0
fun8.3 10/2 10/3 +0 -1
fun8.4 13/3 12/2 +1 +1
fun8.5 16/2 13/2 +3 +0
fun9.1 6/2 6/2 +0 +0
fun9.2 10/2 7/2 +3 +0
fun9.3 11/3 9/2 +2 +1
fun9.4 13/2 10/3 +3 -1
fun9.5 16/3 12/2 +4 +1
skipped (not scorable under either criterion): []
ours approach 808 endgame 932 total 1740 (46% of the cost is approach)
chandrupatla approach 698 endgame 789 total 1487 (47% of the cost is approach)
GAP: approach +110, endgame +143 (total +253)
per family (approach gap / endgame gap):
fun1 approach -4 endgame +61
fun5 approach +37 endgame +17
fun4 approach +17 endgame +29
fun3 approach +22 endgame +21
fun6 approach +23 endgame +12
fun9 approach +12 endgame +1
fun8 approach +7 endgame +0
fun2 approach +3 endgame +2
fun7 approach -7 endgame +0