Comparative table of wins and losses (server numbers): five variants of the proposed rule against library Chandrupatla, Brent, TOMS748 - totals, per-problem sign tests, wide-bracket families. Server defcontra grid matches the smoke in every projection cell but one (defect+G2 CHA 3183 vs 3182).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-21 16:00:05 +01:00
parent 3d9287ec2c
commit 63cf9fb768
3 changed files with 91 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+TOTALS (evaluations of f, failures charged 200)
+  method                              APS    CHA   both
+  proposed rule                      2806   3220   6026
+  + G2 (step pattern)                2782   3169   5951
+  + G2 + analogy entry               2780   2625   5405
+  + contra + remembered analogy      2792   2537   5329
+  + defect + remembered analogy      2530   2561   5091
+  Chandrupatla                       2787   2441   5228
+  Brent                              2889   4115   7004
+  TOMS748                            2820   4000   6820
+
+PER PROBLEM, ours against each rival: wins/ties/losses (sign-test p)
+  APS
+    proposed rule                    Chandrupatla 87/24/42 p=9.2e-05   Brent 102/11/40 p=2e-07   TOMS748 86/16/51 p=0.0035
+    + G2 (step pattern)              Chandrupatla 95/20/38 p=8.2e-07   Brent 110/9/34 p=1.5e-10   TOMS748 97/15/41 p=2.1e-06
+    + G2 + analogy entry             Chandrupatla 95/20/38 p=8.2e-07   Brent 110/9/34 p=1.5e-10   TOMS748 97/15/41 p=2.1e-06
+    + contra + remembered analogy    Chandrupatla 90/23/40 p=1.4e-05   Brent 105/11/37 p=9.9e-09   TOMS748 87/16/50 p=0.002
+    + defect + remembered analogy    Chandrupatla 86/20/47 p=0.00091   Brent 101/13/39 p=1.6e-07   TOMS748 107/11/35 p=1.1e-09
+  CHA
+    proposed rule                    Chandrupatla 9/5/26 p=0.006   Brent 30/4/4 p=6.2e-06   TOMS748 31/1/8 p=0.00029
+    + G2 (step pattern)              Chandrupatla 10/3/27 p=0.0076   Brent 30/2/6 p=7e-05   TOMS748 31/1/8 p=0.00029
+    + G2 + analogy entry             Chandrupatla 9/6/25 p=0.009   Brent 30/2/6 p=7e-05   TOMS748 36/1/3 p=3.6e-08
+    + contra + remembered analogy    Chandrupatla 8/7/25 p=0.0046   Brent 31/4/3 p=7.7e-07   TOMS748 37/1/2 p=2.8e-09
+    + defect + remembered analogy    Chandrupatla 8/5/27 p=0.0019   Brent 30/2/6 p=7e-05   TOMS748 35/1/4 p=3.4e-07
+
+CHA PER FAMILY (ours / Chandrupatla)
+                                       fun1     fun2     fun3     fun4     fun5     fun6     fun7     fun8     fun9
+  proposed rule                          99      141      338      573      456      456     1000       52      105
+  + G2 (step pattern)                    97      146      346      522      456      456     1000       52       94
+  + G2 + analogy entry                   99      146      336      331      254      313     1000       52       94
+  + contra + remembered analogy         108      141      304      318      254      275     1000       52       85
+  + defect + remembered analogy         123      144      304      315      257      280     1000       57       81
+  Chandrupatla                          103      152      305      297      233      233     1000       63       55