Valeri's objection measured: the principle is right (a similarity step should be large far away and small near), and our sigma = |f'|D defeats it — at x=1e4 on a 2e4 bracket the normalised residual is 0.167, so S=0.833 'similar' and the step is small five thousand step-lengths from the root. Selecting sigma = min(|f'|D, max|f| at the ends) — no new constant — improves 403 to 390 on eight hand-picked wide problems but is WORSE over the grid: APS 3288 vs 2726, CHA 3111 vs 2683, so the mode is rejected by its pre-registered rule. Its extra solves are two fun7 problems landing inside the flat zero region, i.e. the scoring artefact and not a capability. Written into Negative results as the answer to the natural objection
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
|
||||
sweep: 63 configurations x 199 problems (FULL)
|
||||
10/63 done, 1s elapsed
|
||||
20/63 done, 1s elapsed
|
||||
30/63 done, 1s elapsed
|
||||
40/63 done, 1s elapsed
|
||||
50/63 done, 1s elapsed
|
||||
60/63 done, 1s elapsed
|
||||
63/63 done, 2s elapsed
|
||||
wrote sweep_cap.json (2s total)
|
||||
====================================================================================
|
||||
APS: 154 problems (top 20 of 63)
|
||||
====================================================================================
|
||||
configuration solved total fev over 2x
|
||||
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.none 153/154 3288 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.project 153/154 3288 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.step 153/154 3385 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.safe 153/154 3385 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.step 153/154 3460 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.safe 153/154 3460 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.none 153/154 3497 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.project 153/154 3497 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.bracket 153/154 3537 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.both 153/154 3619 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.credit 153/154 4125 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.bracket 153/154 4333 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.both 153/154 4903 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.credit 153/154 5001 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.step 153/154 5044 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.safe 153/154 5044 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.step 153/154 6184 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.safe 153/154 6184 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.both 153/154 6216 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.bracket 153/154 6580 0
|
||||
|
||||
====================================================================================
|
||||
CHA: 45 problems (top 20 of 63)
|
||||
====================================================================================
|
||||
configuration solved total fev over 2x
|
||||
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.none 42/45 2969 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.project 41/45 3111 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.step 40/45 2658 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.safe 40/45 2658 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.both 40/45 2689 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.step 40/45 2790 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.safe 40/45 2790 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.bracket 40/45 2796 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.none 40/45 2808 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.project 40/45 2808 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.both 40/45 2906 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.step 40/45 2959 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.safe 40/45 2959 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.none 40/45 2970 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.project 40/45 2970 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.ratio.derived3_cap.bracket 40/45 2978 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.rational.derived3_cap.credit 40/45 2982 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.exp_abs.derived3_cap.credit 40/45 2991 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.cbrt.derived3_cap.both 40/45 3041 0
|
||||
pure+dissim+slope.sqrt.derived3_cap.step 40/45 3066 0
|
||||
|
||||
====================================================================================
|
||||
THE STAGE-0C LAW ACROSS THE GRID
|
||||
====================================================================================
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user