vvs/sim-numerics
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Article: ModAB added - Table 8 row (2914 / 2436 / 5350; A' 118/11/25 and 32/9/4), Table 10 column (totals, bound violations, A' vs ModAB per corpus), how it is run (authors' package pymodab 1.0.9, same stopping rule, counts agree with the package's own), the evidence paragraph (ahead on every corpus p <= 0.0013, the one test 3656 vs 5535 183/34, ModAB's own benchmark all 91: 1507 vs 1588, 9 bound violations), 8.6: ModAB's linearity check at the midpoint named as the precursor of our exit judgment, abstract, conclusion, introduction, future work (the comparison no longer missing), reference 20. verify_article: every ModAB number checked; server 467 OK, 0 BAD; regression x2 1226 passed, 0 failed.

Browse Source 
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
vvs
2026-09-21 21:42:15 +01:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5
parent 37c81b027a
commit f80aeb5d13
4 changed files with 185 additions and 16 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
results_verify_article.txt
+23
View File
@@ -440,6 +440,29 @@ Section 9 (out-of-sample corpora):
OK Roots.jl, variant carried: per problem got (38, 10, 30) want (38, 10, 30)
OK applied, variant carried: totals got (1580, 1382) want (1580, 1382)
ModAB (sweep_modab.json, the authors' package):
OK ModAB protocol APS, CHA, both got (2914, 2436, 5350) want (2914, 2436, 5350)
OK A' vs ModAB protocol APS got (118, 11, 25) want (118, 11, 25)
OK A' vs ModAB protocol CHA got (32, 9, 4) want (32, 9, 4)
OK Table 10 ModAB APS got (2726, 0) want (2726, 0)
OK Table 10 A' vs ModAB APS got (118, 10, 26) want (118, 10, 26)
OK Table 10 ModAB CHA got (1681, 0) want (1681, 0)
OK Table 10 A' vs ModAB CHA got (34, 4, 7) want (34, 4, 7)
OK Table 10 ModAB NEW got (3809, 1) want (3809, 1)
OK Table 10 A' vs ModAB NEW got (125, 26, 55) want (125, 26, 55)
OK Table 10 ModAB RJL got (1446, 0) want (1446, 0)
OK Table 10 A' vs ModAB RJL got (47, 11, 20) want (47, 11, 20)
OK Table 10 ModAB APP got (1460, 0) want (1460, 0)
OK Table 10 A' vs ModAB APP got (76, 35, 21) want (76, 35, 21)
OK Table 10 ModAB D got (5535, 8) want (5535, 8)
OK Table 10 A' vs ModAB D got (183, 23, 34) want (183, 23, 34)
OK A' vs ModAB: every corpus p <= 0.0013 got True want True
OK ModAB over all 855 got 16657 want 16657
OK ModAB violations over 855 got 9 want 9
OK corpus 4 A' vs ModAB p (1 digit) got '7e-26' want '7e-26'
OK ModAB's own benchmark, all 91 got (91, 1507, 1588, (56, 13, 22)) want (91, 1507, 1588, (56, 13, 22))
OK ModAB's own benchmark p (2 digits) got '0.00015' want '0.00015'
Table 9a and section 7: the similarity in the step (fresh audit run):
OK Table 9a ratio APS+CHA got 4443 want 4443
OK Table 9a ratio six corpora got 13032 want 13032