sweep: 140 configurations x 199 problems (FULL) wrote sweep_flat2.json (8s total) ==================================================================================== APS: 154 problems (top 20 of 140) ==================================================================================== configuration solved total fev over 2x ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ pure+extP+flat2.ratio.derived3.project 153/154 2781 0 pure+extP+flat2.ratio.derived3.none 153/154 2781 0 pure+extP.ratio.derived3.project 153/154 2782 0 pure+extP.ratio.derived3.none 153/154 2782 0 flat2.ratio.derived3.none 153/154 2803 0 flat2.ratio.derived3.project 153/154 2803 0 pure.ratio.derived3.none 153/154 2806 0 pure.ratio.derived3.project 153/154 2806 0 pure.ratio.derived3.step 153/154 3036 0 pure.ratio.derived3.safe 153/154 3036 0 flat2.ratio.derived3.step 153/154 3042 0 flat2.ratio.derived3.safe 153/154 3042 0 pure+extP.ratio.derived3.step 153/154 3089 0 pure+extP.ratio.derived3.safe 153/154 3089 0 pure+extP+flat2.ratio.derived3.safe 153/154 3097 0 pure+extP+flat2.ratio.derived3.step 153/154 3097 0 flat2.exp_abs.derived3.none 153/154 3257 0 flat2.exp_abs.derived3.project 153/154 3257 0 pure.exp_abs.derived3.none 153/154 3264 0 pure.exp_abs.derived3.project 153/154 3264 0 ==================================================================================== CHA: 45 problems (top 20 of 140) ==================================================================================== configuration solved total fev over 2x ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ flat2.cbrt.derived3.credit 40/45 3016 0 pure.cbrt.derived3.credit 40/45 3016 0 pure.ratio.derived3.credit 40/45 3020 0 flat2.ratio.derived3.credit 40/45 3040 0 pure.exp_abs.derived3.credit 40/45 3049 0 pure.ratio_soft.derived3.credit 40/45 3054 0 flat2.ratio_soft.derived3.credit 40/45 3054 0 pure+extP.ratio.derived3.credit 40/45 3064 0 flat2.exp_abs.derived3.credit 40/45 3066 0 pure+extP+flat2.ratio.derived3.credit 40/45 3084 0 pure.cosine.derived3.credit 40/45 3129 0 flat2.cosine.derived3.credit 40/45 3129 0 pure.exp_sq.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 flat2.exp_sq.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 pure.rat_sq.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 flat2.rat_sq.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 flat2.rational.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 pure.rational.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 pure.sqrt.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 flat2.sqrt.derived3.credit 40/45 3130 0 ==================================================================================== THE STAGE-0C LAW ACROSS THE GRID ==================================================================================== scale=derived3 slope c=1 (linear) mean total 6829 mean solved 193.0/199 scale=derived3 slope c=0 (quadratic) mean total 19620 mean solved 193.0/199 tent, 3-point, pairs (no gate -> flat gate) APS CHA both flat fun3-6 none 2806->2803 4104->3571 6910->6374 2707->2205 solved 193 over 15 none +G2 2782->2781 3863->3585 6645->6366 2474->2217 solved 193 over 15 step 3036->3042 3524->3522 6560->6564 2111->2111 solved 193 over 15 step +G2 3089->3097 3529->3528 6618->6625 2106->2106 solved 193 over 15 bracket 7260->7260 3604->3604 10864->10864 1730->1730 solved 193 over 0 bracket +G2 6837->6837 3650->3650 10487->10487 1717->1717 solved 193 over 0 both 7239->7239 3515->3515 10754->10754 1529->1529 solved 193 over 0 both +G2 7130->7130 3463->3463 10593->10593 1504->1504 solved 193 over 0 project 2806->2803 3220->3341 6026->6144 1823->1975 solved 193 over 0 project +G2 2782->2781 3169->3345 5951->6126 1780->1977 solved 193 over 0 safe 3036->3042 3390->3388 6426->6430 1977->1977 solved 193 over 0 safe +G2 3089->3097 3392->3386 6481->6483 1969->1964 solved 193 over 0 credit 3568->3603 3020->3040 6588->6643 1044->1064 solved 193 over 0 credit +G2 3799->3800 3064->3084 6863->6884 1044->1064 solved 193 over 0 VERDICTS proposed rule APS 2806->2803 (Z2 ✓) CHA 3220->3341 (Z1 ✗) Z3 ✓ (0 viol, 0 cells <193) Z4 ✗ both 6144 vs Chandrupatla APS 83/28/42 p=0.00031 not accepted proposed rule + G2 APS 2782->2781 (Z2 ✓) CHA 3169->3345 (Z1 ✗) Z3 ✓ (0 viol, 0 cells <193) Z4 ✗ both 6126 vs Chandrupatla APS 92/21/40 p=7e-06 not accepted nine functions, projection, no gate -> flat gate, both sets: cbrt 18003 -> 18006 cosine 19741 -> 18984 exp_abs 6652 -> 6858 exp_sq 19786 -> 16993 rat_sq 19793 -> 17677 ratio 6026 -> 6144 ratio_soft 9352 -> 9299 rational 6823 -> 6908 sqrt 13388 -> 13416